Yonma-yon
Tickmill vs XM Group
Tickmill vs XM Group — Xarajat, tartibga solish, leveraj, platformalar va faoliyat tarixi bo'yicha to'g'ridan-to'g'ri taqqoslash.
KuzatuvchiBrokerlist Editorial · Mustaqil sharh jamoasiYangilangan
In short. Choose Tickmill if siz EI yoki UK chakana savdosiz va ECN-style komissiya narxlashi bilan ikki tomonlama FCA + CySEC qamrovini xohlaysiz. Choose XM Group if ro'yxatimizdagi eng past ishqalanish kirishini xohlaysiz — minimum depozit $5.
Yonma-yon faktlar
Hukm qisqacha
Umumiy durang
- Tickmill
- 2 mezonda yetakchi
- XM Group
- 2 mezonda yetakchi
- Durang
- 1 durang
Lot uchun pastroq xarajat
Tickmill: $8.00/lot, XM Group: $13.00/lot. Lower at Tickmill.
Yangi boshlanuvchilar uchun yaxshiroq
Tickmill: $100, XM Group: $5. Smaller minimum at XM Group.
Yuqoriroq chakana leveraj
Tickmill: 1:1000, XM Group: 1:1000. Same maximum leverage.
Kuchliroq tartibga solish qamrovi
Tickmill: FCA, CySEC, FSA, FSCA, XM Group: ASIC, CySEC, IFSC. Stronger licensing at Tickmill.
Kengroq platforma tanlovi
Tickmill: MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, XM Group: MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, Web Trader. Wider platform choice at XM Group.
Pros and cons
Tickmill
Pros
- ✓Raw hisob: spredlar 0.0 dan + $6 aylanma — komissiya darajasida ECN-uslubidagi narxlash
Cons
- ✕Broker faqat "dan boshlab" spredlarini eʼlon qiladi — hisob sahifasida haqiqiy odatiy qiymatlar oshkor qilinmagan
- ✕cTrader yoʻq — faqat MT4/MT5
- ✕16 yurisdiktsiyada mavjud emas, jumladan AQSh, Kanada, Yaponiya, Rossiya/Belarus va OFAC sanksiyalari ostidagi mamlakatlar
XM Group
Pros
- ✓$5 eng kam — qulay kirish
- ✓Yangi boshlovchilar uchun sifatli taʼlim mazmuni
Cons
- ✕Standard hisob EUR/USD spredlari 1.0–1.6 pip (broker tomonidan eʼlon qilingan oraliq) + $0 komissiya ≈ $13/lot — bu roʻyxatdagi eng qimmatlardan biri
- ✕Uzoq faolsizlikdan keyin taxminan $5/oy faolsizlik toʻlovi
- ✕EU chakana mijozlari qatʼiyroq CySEC boʻlimiga yoʻnaltiriladi; ofshor XM Global tashkiloti yuqori leveraj bilan EU boʻlmagan trafikni qayta ishlaydi
- ✕AQSh, Kanada, Isroil yoki Eron aholisini qabul qilmaydi (broker roʻyxatsiz boshqa cheklovlarni daʼvo qiladi)
Who should choose which
Choose Tickmill if:
- ✓Siz EI yoki UK chakana savdosiz va ECN-style komissiya narxlashi bilan ikki tomonlama FCA + CySEC qamrovini xohlaysiz
- ✓Skalping yoki algo-savdo qilasiz: Raw hisobining ~$6 aylanma Raw komissiyasi + 0,0-dan spred ECN-fokusli brokerlar bilan raqobatbardosh
- ✓Wire orqali $5 000+ depozit qo'yasiz — Tickmill bank tomoni to'lovlarini ~$100 gacha qoplaydi, toifa uchun odatiy emas
- ✓Osiyodasiz va UnionPay moliyalashtirishni xohlaysiz — uni taklif qiladigan brokerlarimizdan biri
- ✓An'anaviy usullardan voz kechmagan holda kripto moliyalashtirish (USDT, BTC) xohlaysiz
Choose XM Group if:
- ✓Ro'yxatimizdagi eng past ishqalanish kirishini xohlaysiz — minimum depozit $5
- ✓Boshqa brokerlar to'lov oladigan to'lov usullarini ishlatasiz — XM «no-fees» siyosati ko'pchilik karta va e-hamyon to'lovlarini qoplaydi
- ✓Siz AU chakana savdosiz va ikki tomonlama ASIC + CySEC qamrovini xohlaysiz
- ✓Yangi boshlovchisiz va onboarding qismi sifatida brokerning ta'lim mazmunini qadrlaysiz
- ✓Western Union yoki MoneyGram moliyalashtirish kerak — brokerlarimiz orasida nodir qo'llab-quvvatlash
Agar hisob ochsangiz, biz komissiya olishimiz mumkin, ammo bu bizning reytingimiz yoki baholarimizga hech qachon ta'sir qilmaydi. Qanday daromad olamiz.
Frequently asked
Which is better — Tickmill or XM Group?+
Across our 5 dimensions: Tickmill leads in 2, XM Group in 2, ties: 1. Overall verdict: tied. Full breakdown below.
Which broker has lower fees?+
Cost-per-lot in our calculation: Tickmill — $8.00, XM Group — $13.00. Lower at Tickmill.
Which is better for beginners?+
Minimum deposit: Tickmill — $100, XM Group — $5. Easier onboarding at XM Group.
What trading platforms do they offer?+
Tickmill: MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5. XM Group: MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, Web Trader.
Who regulates each broker?+
Tickmill: FCA, CySEC, FSA, FSCA. XM Group: ASIC, CySEC, IFSC.